Skip to main content

Book Review - Train to Pakistan


Train to Pakistan

Author: Khushwant Singh

Publication: Ravi Dayal Publishers / Penguin Books Pvt Ltd., 

Before getting into the book review its important to know about the author. Khushwant Singh was a senior Journalist, writer, lawyer, diplomat & Politician. He was a Member of Parliament (Rajya Shaba) during 1980s. His views on politics were from Liberal School of thought. He was honored with Padma Vibushan in 2007. 

He's also known for his controversies, too. Returned Padma Bhusan during Golden Temple incident in 1980s. Openly praised the internal emergency announced by Ms. Indira Gandhi in 1970s. Many doesn't know the fact that he is a close friend of former PM Dr.Manmohan Singh. They had very close relationship that Khushwant Singh had financed Dr.MMS for the latter' election expenses during 1990s. Khushwant Singh passed away in 2014. 

Lets get into the story. Train to Pakistan is a novel written by the author during 1950s based on the biggest human migration in the world history i.e., Partition of Indian and Pakistan in 1947. 

The story shows the real tragedy of Partition through the eyes of a remote border village named 'Mano Majra'. Its a village mostly with Muslims and Sikhs. He depicts how peace the village was in the starting pages of the story. As it is a remote village, its mostly unaware of the happenings in the rest of the subcontinent, until a train with full of Sikh/Hindu dead bodies arrived at the village, from Pakistan who tried to cross the border to India. 

The story moves though the eyes of a stranger who had came to the village on his way and Juggut Singh, who is a local gangster, he's in love with a Muslim girl. The story captures the government structure & functioning during the period, including how rude the Britishers in fueling the communal riot and how incompetent the local Magistrate & local Police w.r.t the powers to control the riots. 

The partition saw a huge number of fatalities along both sides of the Radcliffe line (which separates Indian&Pakistan). Woman became the primary target of the rioters and many of them (unofficial figures say about 83,000 womens) were raped by the rioters. The author recorded the same without any bias.

He busted many myths about the communal riots and gave an ideal work on that, through his words, 

“Muslims said the Hindus had planned and started the killing. According to the Hindus, the Muslims were to blame. The fact is, both sides killed. Both shot and stabbed and speared and clubbed. Both tortured. Both raped”

There were many speculations during the time, even today, that every Muslim wanted to go to Pakistan. He denied the same through these lines: 

“What have we to do with Pakistan? We were born here. So were our ancestors. We have lived amongst [Sikhs] as brothers”

By showing the pre-cautionary steps taken by the local Magistrate to operate the train, with Muslims who wanted to cross the border and to reach Pakistan, in mid-night without light and without horn, author conveyed how inflammable the situation was. The extremists in Hindu religion planned for mid-night assault on Muslims, who were on their way to cross the border, as an revenge to the assault done against Hindus/Muslims. By the way the author conveyed that riot doesn't have religion-race-caste. 

Juggut Singh tried to save his lover, whom he thought had left to Pakistan in the train. Novel completes with the following lines, which explains the result of his attempt to save her:  

“The train went over him, and went on to Pakistan

Rather than a novel its an important document which conveys the real tragedy of Partition. Everyone who loves history, must give it a read.

Dinesh
02.06.2020

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Book Review - சில நேரங்களில் சில மனிதர்கள்!

சில நேரங்களில் சில  மனிதர்கள்! ஆசிரியர்: ஜெயகாந்தன்  வெளியீடு: மீனாட்சி புத்தக நிலையம்   எ ழுத்துலகின் பீஷ்மன் என்று புகழப்படும் ஜெயகாந்தனால் ஏறக்குறைய 50 ஆண்டுகளுக்கு முன் எழுதப்பட்டது இந்த கதை. ஜெயகாந்தன் எழுதிய ' அக்னி பிரவேசம் ' என்ற சர்ச்சைக்குரிய சிறுகதையை மையமாக வைத்து எழுதப்பட்டதே இந்த நெடுங்கதை. சில நேரங்களில் சில மனிதர்கள் கதயை பார்க்கும் முன், அக்னி பிரவேசம் பற்றி தெரிந்து கொள்வது அவசியமாகிறது. அக்னி பிரவேசம் கதையின் சுருக்கம் இதுவே:  கல்லூரிக்கு முதல் நாள் செல்லும் பாரம்பரிய பிராமண  குடும்பத்தை சார்த்த   இளம் பெண் சந்தர்ப்ப சூழ்நிலையால் முன்பின் அறிமுகம் இல்லாத மூன்றாம் நபருடன் காரில் வீடு திரும்ப நேரிடுகிறது. தனிமையை பயன்படுத்திக்கொள்ளும் அந்த வாலிபர், பெண்ணை தன் இச்சைக்கு பயன்படுத்திவிட்ட பிறகு வீட்டில் விட்டு செல்கிறார். நடந்தவற்றை தாயிடம் சொல்கிறாள் மகள். கைம்பெண்ணான  தாய்  இந்த விடயத்தை மகனுக்கு கூட சொல்லாமல், பெண்ணை மாற்றானுக்கு மணம்முடிப்பதாக கதை முடிகிறது. இன்றைய காலகட்டத்திற்கு இது சாதாரணமாக, முற்ப...

Germany Days-3

The very next day was maximum of travelling. We left to  Braunschweig via ICE (Inter-City Express). We had the breakfast from the hotel and taken a parcel for afternoon, as we'll be mostly travelling for the day. The plan was to have a changeover at Frankfurt and take the second train to reach our destination. But for our surprise, the train was running late for about 40 minutes, co-passengers said that this is not usual. Due to the delay, our plan got changed. Instead of changing in Frankfurt, we were asked to change in Hannover.  We were travelling in the reserved coach and we were not sure whether someone will come there to occupy the seat after Frankfurt, as our original reservation was till then. Finally we managed to reach Hannover without any hassle. Till now we had seen the country, which is quite calm , neat and less populated. But the scene in Hanover was completely different. The station was so crowded and it was not that clean. We all were puzzled and even to board...

Germany Days- 5, 6 & 7

Day 5 Today was supposed to be the last day of our official tour, but I had other plans. I decided to stay back for one more day to explore the local areas. Fortunately, one of my colleagues from the cohort also had the same idea, and she knew a local who had helped us. After breakfast, we left the hotel and took public transport to the meeting location. Some key persons we met during the trip attended this final meeting. We were joined by representatives from the Ministry, and together we provided feedback on the agenda we had been following throughout the tour and suggested a few action items. Honestly, I’m not sure how many of those will be implemented, but we don’t have much say in that. The official tour concluded with a networking lunch, and we were free for the rest of the day. The group decided to return to the hotel for a quick siesta and then visit the market area in the evening. Berlin, the capital, was undergoing numerous construction projects, and we saw "work in prog...